Is Unilever a Better Pick Than Procter & Gamble?

  • Weekly Giveaway for our active users. N50,000 per Week. Do you want to contribute to this community? We are looking for contribution? What is hot right now? Sign up and get in on the ground floor of the newest, fastest growing Nigerian forum!

Samiat

Member
Nov 12, 2024
151
3
18
Is Unilever a Better Pick Than Procter & Gamble?

While Procter & Gamble (NYSE: PG) has historically performed well, Unilever (NYSE: UL) could offer better long-term potential. Unilever’s stock trades at a more affordable valuation of 19 times forward earnings compared to P&G’s 26 times. With Unilever showing volume growth across its key categories, it’s positioned to narrow the gap with P&G. Below, we break down why Unilever might outperform P&G in the coming years based on factors like revenue growth, profitability, and valuation.

1. Performance: P&G Outpaced Unilever in the Past
Stock Returns: Over the last few years, P&G has delivered better returns than Unilever. From early 2021 to now, P&G’s stock rose 45% (from $125 to $180), while Unilever’s stock grew modestly, moving from $55 to $60.

Market Comparison: Both stocks have underperformed compared to the broader S&P 500 index, which gained 60% over the same period.

Recent Struggles: Unilever has faced challenges, with its stock losing value in 2021 (-8%) and 2022 (-3%). P&G has also seen inconsistent returns, such as a 21% gain in 2021, followed by a 5% drop in 2022.

2. Revenue Growth: P&G Leads, But Unilever Shows Promise

P&G’s Growth: P&G’s revenue has grown at an annual average of 3.4%, rising from $76.2 billion in fiscal 2021 to $84 billion in fiscal 2024. This growth has been largely driven by pricing increases rather than higher sales volumes.
Unilever’s Growth: Unilever’s revenue increased by just 0.9% annually (from $62.4 billion in 2020 to $63.9 billion in 2023).

However, when measured in Euros, the company’s revenue grew at 5.7% annually, highlighting the impact of currency fluctuations.

Volume Gains: Unilever’s recent performance is encouraging, with a 4.3% sales increase for the first nine months of 2024, driven by a 2.9% rise in volume and a 1.3% pricing gain. This shift toward volume growth signals a more sustainable strategy compared to relying solely on price hikes.

Category Highlights: Personal care and home care have been strong segments for Unilever, supported by brands like Dove.

Challenges for P&G: P&G’s beauty and baby care segments are facing headwinds. Beauty sales, particularly in China, dropped 5% in the last quarter, with skincare falling 20%. Baby diapers are also losing market share, impacting overall growth.

3. Profitability and Financial Health: P&G Stands Out

Profit Margins: P&G remains more profitable, with a 19.4% adjusted net margin in 2024 compared to Unilever’s 10.4%.

Debt Levels: P&G has a stronger financial position, with debt representing just 9% of its equity compared to Unilever’s 23%. Additionally, P&G has grown its cash reserves from $10.3 billion to $12.2 billion over three years, while Unilever’s cash holdings declined from $6.8 billion to $4.5 billion.

Financial Cushion: P&G’s higher cash-to-asset ratio (10%) gives it a better buffer than Unilever (6%).

4. Valuation and Future Outlook
Current Valuations: Both stocks are trading above their historical averages, suggesting limited near-term upside.

Unilever: Trading at 19 times forward earnings ($3.11 per share), slightly above its three-year average of 18 times.

P&G: Trading at 26 times forward earnings ($6.94 per share), compared to its three-year average of 24 times.

Outlook for Unilever: Unilever’s focus on volume growth, supported by strong segments like home care and well-being products, positions it for better long-term gains. While P&G has seen stronger revenue growth and remains more profitable, challenges in its beauty and baby care segments could weigh on its performance.

Bottom Line: Why Unilever Could Outperform

While Procter & Gamble offers stronger profitability and a more stable financial position, Unilever’s shift to volume-driven growth across categories like personal and home care gives it an edge for long-term potential. For investors seeking robust returns over the next three years, Unilever appears to be the better bet.